System Design Interview Topic: Vertical / Horizontal Scaling

Join me to stay up-to-date and get my new articles delivered to your inbox by subscribing here.

January 26, 2023

Distributed Systems  System Design Interview 

Introduction: System design interviews are a crucial part of technical interviews for software engineering roles. They assess a candidate’s ability to design scalable, reliable, and efficient systems. Two common concepts that frequently come up in system design interviews are vertical scaling and horizontal scaling. In this blog post, we’ll delve into these concepts, understand their differences, and explore how they can be applied in real-world system design scenarios.

Vertical Scaling: Vertical scaling, also known as scaling up, refers to increasing the capacity of a single server by adding more resources, such as CPU, memory, or storage, to the existing hardware. It involves upgrading the existing server’s hardware to handle more load and provide better performance. For example, adding more RAM to a server to handle increased traffic or upgrading the CPU to improve processing speed. Vertical scaling is typically done by replacing the hardware components of a server or adding additional hardware to the server.

Pros of Vertical Scaling:

  • Simpler to implement as it involves upgrading or adding resources to an existing server.
  • Requires fewer maintenance efforts as there is no need to manage multiple servers.
  • Can be cost-effective for small-scale applications with limited resources.

Cons of Vertical Scaling:

  • Limited scalability as there is a physical limit to the number of resources that can be added to a single server.
  • This can result in a single point of failure as all the application’s load is concentrated on a single server.
  • May not be cost-effective for large-scale applications with high traffic and resource requirements.

Horizontal Scaling: Horizontal scaling, also known as scaling out, refers to adding more servers to a system to distribute the load and increase capacity. In horizontal scaling, new servers are added to the existing infrastructure, and load is distributed among them using techniques like load balancing. Each server operates independently and can handle a portion of the overall load. Horizontal scaling enables a system to handle increased traffic by adding more servers as needed.

Pros of Horizontal Scaling:

  • Highly scalable as new servers can be added to the system to handle the increased load.
  • Provides better fault tolerance as there is no single point of failure, and the load is distributed across multiple servers.
  • Can be cost-effective for large-scale applications with high traffic and resource requirements, as resources can be added incrementally as needed.

Cons of Horizontal Scaling:

  • Can be more complex to implement as it requires managing multiple servers and load-balancing mechanisms.
  • May require additional efforts to ensure data consistency and coordination among multiple servers.
  • Requires additional maintenance efforts compared to vertical scaling as there are multiple servers to manage.

Use Cases for Vertical and Horizontal Scaling:

Vertical Scaling:

  • Small-scale applications with limited resource requirements.
  • Applications with predictable and stable workloads that do not require frequent scaling.
  • Applications with a small user base or limited traffic.

Horizontal Scaling:

  • Large-scale applications with high traffic and resource requirements.
  • Applications with variable or unpredictable workloads that require frequent scaling.
  • Applications with a large user base and complex processing requirements.

Conclusion: In system design interviews, understanding the concepts of vertical and horizontal scaling is essential. Vertical scaling involves upgrading or adding resources to an existing server and is simpler to implement, but has limitations in scalability. Horizontal scaling involves adding more servers to a system and is highly scalable, but can be more complex to implement. Both approaches have their pros and cons, and their suitability depends on the specific requirements of the application. Being able to explain and justify the choice between vertical and horizontal scaling in system design scenarios is a crucial skill for any software engineer.